Our nation's elementary schools employ 1.9 million teachers who are prepared by programs housed in over 1,500 separate institutions. Since 2006, NCTQ has reviewed programs, made recommendations, and highlighted the best we've seen of key elements for undergraduate, graduate, and non-traditional elementary programs.
The NCTQ Teacher Prep Review evaluates the quality of programs that provide preservice preparation of teachers. The Review database includes both traditional and non-traditional programs.
Traditional Programs
The Teacher Prep Review evaluates a total of 1,244 undergraduate and graduate elementary programs offered by education schools in 1,053 public and private institutions of higher education. The institution-based programs evaluated under the Teacher Prep Review are responsible for producing 96 percent of traditionally prepared teachers.
Alternative Route and Residency Programs
The Teacher Prep Review also examines 58 alternate route and residency programs leading to elementary certification.
Elementary Mathematics: Only one in eight teacher prep programs across the country dedicate sufficient time to teaching fundamental math content topics in 2025. The average undergraduate program dedicates 85 instructional hours to this content, 20 hours shy of the recommended minimum, while graduate programs fare far worse, dedicating an average of only 14 hours.
Reading Foundations: 50+ years of research has provided clear evidence on how to most effectively teach children to read, yet new NCTQ data shows only 25% of teacher prep programs ensure future teachers learn these methods.
Building Content Knowledge: While 84% of institutions address most science and social studies content elementary teachers need within current course options, only 3% require candidates to take the right courses in most topics.
Teacher Licensure Pass Rate Data: Institutional pass rates on elementary content licensure tests provide key insights on ways to better support aspiring teachers. Explore our work to support a data-driven approach to building a stronger, more diverse teacher workforce.
Program Diversity: A diverse teacher workforce benefits all students, particularly students of color — yet only 21% of teacher prep programs enroll cohorts of future teachers that are as racially diverse as their state teacher workforce and local community.
Admissions: Setting more rigorous admissions standards for aspiring teachers supports student learning. However, too many teacher prep programs don't set a high bar for admission.
Clinical Practice: No aspect of teacher prep is more influential than clinical practice, yet only 4% of programs ensure mentor teachers have the skills necessary to effectively mentor teacher candidates — an obstacle that persists in part because programs leave the selection of mentors to K-12 districts.
Classroom Management: Half of traditional elementary programs ensure that student teachers learn to use at least four of the five classroom management strategies that are universally effective, regardless of student age or the subject being taught—an increase of almost 30% since 2013.
NCTQ reviews elementary teacher preparation programs against seven research-based standards that are proven to have the greatest impact on teacher effectiveness and student learning outcomes.
New NCTQ data provides an in-depth analysis of whether teacher prep programs are preparing aspiring teachers in the most effective instructional methods for teaching children to read.